Stop Asking Employees What Training They Want

November 17, 2026

Every year, organisations send employees a familiar survey question: “What training would you like next year?” The responses arrive predictably. Leadership. Communication. Excel. Customer service. AI. Time management. Negotiation. Someone converts the results into percentages, produces a colourful chart and announces that the Training Needs Analysis is complete.

I am not always convinced that it is. What we may have produced is a training wish list.

Employees absolutely should have a voice in their development because they know where they struggle, where they want to grow and what parts of their work feel difficult. But asking employees, “What training do you want?” can quietly assume something we have not yet established: that training is the answer.

One of my favourite questions when conducting a needs assessment is simply:

“What is the real problem that you are trying to solve?”

It is an open question, and I have found that it often changes the conversation completely.

I remember one organisation where management was convinced that their direct reports needed conflict-management training. That was the brief, and we could easily have accepted it, designed a conflict-management programme and delivered exactly what had been requested.

But the needs assessment revealed something very different. The more significant development need was among senior management, particularly around coaching and delegation. The conflict among their direct reports was real, but simply training those employees in conflict management would have addressed the symptom without dealing sufficiently with the management practices contributing to the situation.

That is precisely why diagnosis matters. Sometimes the people a client wants you to train are not the people who most need development.

“The phrase ‘we need training’ is a conclusion. A good L&D professional wants to know what evidence brought us there.” Margaret Jackson

Consider another example. An employee requests time-management training. Perhaps she genuinely needs it, but perhaps two positions on her team have been vacant for six months, every request is labeled urgent, her manager changes priorities throughout the day, and the approval process requires eleven signatures and possibly divine intervention. We can give her a planner and teach her the Eisenhower Matrix, but the impossible workload will still be waiting when she returns.

This is where the questions we ask become critical. Instead of “What training do you need?”, I am much more interested in questions such as: Where are you struggling to perform? What makes this part of your job difficult? What has changed in your role? What gets in the way of doing the work well? Those questions begin to reveal the performance problem rather than merely collect course preferences.

CIPD’s guidance on learning-needs analysis takes this broader approach by recommending that organizations begin with current and future capability requirements and examine needs at individual, team and organizational levels using multiple sources of evidence. That matters because employees know what work feels like, managers see performance from another angle, leaders understand where the business is going, customers experience the consequences, and performance data sometimes tells a story nobody has mentioned.

L&D has to connect those dots.

The same applies when managers arrive with the solution already prescribed. “We need leadership training.” “We need customer-service training.” “Our people need resilience training.” Perhaps they do, but I want to understand what is actually happening first.

That is where performance consulting differs from order-taking. The order-taker hears “We need leadership training” and asks, “How many participants?” The performance consultant asks, “What are your managers doing, or not doing, that is causing concern?” Those two questions lead to very different conversations because one begins with logistics while the other begins with diagnosis.

I have even told paying clients that I do not believe they need training, and they are often shocked by the honesty. Perhaps they expect a training provider to sell training rather than advise them not to buy it, but if my diagnosis suggests that the real issue is management, process, structure, systems, or job design, I find it difficult to recommend a workshop simply because I can deliver one.

There may be a commercial cost to saying no, but there is also professional credibility in being willing to say it. In my experience, that honesty changes the relationship because I am no longer simply the person selling training; I am helping the client think more clearly about performance.

“The value of L&D is not in how quickly we can say yes to a training request. Sometimes our greatest value lies in asking enough questions to discover that the organisation needs something else.” Margaret Jackson

This matters strategically too. The World Economic Forum’s Future of Jobs Report 2025 found that 63% of employers see skills gaps as a major barrier to business transformation. If capability gaps can derail transformation, identifying the right gaps cannot be left to a popularity contest about which courses people would enjoy attending.

Perhaps we should also accept some responsibility for why employees continue to request courses. Many development forms still contain a box labeled “Training required”, so people duly fill it with course titles and then we wonder why everyone thinks development means training.

We gave them the box.

What if we asked instead, “What do you need to become better able to do, why does it matter, and what experiences might help you develop that capability?” That question immediately widens the conversation because coaching, mentoring, stretch assignments, supervised practice, job shadowing, peer learning, and workplace experience can enter alongside formal training.

So no, I am not suggesting that we stop listening to employees, and I am certainly not campaigning against surveys. Please keep your Microsoft Forms account. 😄 I suggest we stop confusing a course-preference survey with a needs diagnosis.

Ask employees what they want to learn, but also ask where the work is breaking down, what is changing, what prevents good performance, and what capability they will need next. Talk to managers, examine the evidence, understand the business, and keep asking the question that matters most:

“What is the real problem that you are trying to solve?”

Then listen carefully, because the answer may confirm the course everyone asked for, reveal a very different need or tell you that you should not design a course at all.

That is not L&D failing to provide training.

That is L&D doing its job.


Author(s)


Comments